IN THIS LESSON
Remote Viewing · Lesson 6 of 8
The Great Debate
Did the remote viewers beat chance, and if they did, what did it mean? Marks and Kammann's cues in the Stanford transcripts, and the replies; the National Research Council's review of 1988; Jessica Utts and Ray Hyman, the two reviewers of 1995, who agreed on the numbers but not on their meaning, and the panel's verdict; the ganzfeld and its rival meta-analyses; a meta-analysis of remote viewing in 2023; and the Transparent Psi Project, a test that proponents and sceptics designed together.
Remote viewing became famous through a paper in Nature in October 1974 (The Stanford Experiments), and it has been argued over ever since. Like the argument over the mediums before it (The Investigators), it was never simply a quarrel between believers and scoffers. By 1995 the two reviewers chosen to weigh the evidence, one a defender and one a critic, agreed that the laboratory hits beat chance, and disagreed about what that showed. The question that runs through the whole debate is narrower and harder than "is it real?": when a description matches its target better than chance, what else could have done it?
Cues in the transcripts
In Nature in August 1978, D. Marks and R. Kammann of the University of Otago pointed out that the transcripts SRI's judges had matched to the sites contained cues: dates, mentions of earlier targets, remarks by the experimenters. Because each site had been used only once, such cues could let a judge put the transcripts in the right order with no psychic information at all. A transcript that mentioned yesterday's site, for instance, could not be yesterday's.
In 1980 C. T. Tart, H. E. Puthoff and R. Targ replied that they had edited out the suspected cues and had the nine transcripts of Pat Price's series judged again by an independent judge, who matched seven of the nine. Marks answered in 1981 with a note titled "Sensory cues invalidate remote viewing experiments". In 1986, when he and Scott were at last allowed to see the edited transcripts, they reported under the title "Remote viewing exposed" that cues remained. Marks's own attempts to repeat the experiments reportedly failed. Even Jessica Utts, who later defended the programme's results, accepted that cueing was possible and could not be ruled out for the early series.
Lesson 6 of 8 · 17 min