IN THIS LESSON
Deep Study · Lesson 2 of 6
On the Mysteries — Iamblichus and the Case for Ritual
Why a fourth-century philosopher argued that rites, symbols and strange names do what thinking alone cannot, read through his own reply to Porphyry's hard questions.
Every ritual magician eventually meets the philosopher's objection. If the gods are perfect, unchanging and beyond all passion, what can a ritual do to them? Why should incense, chants or a name spoken in a foreign tongue move a god who is pure mind? Late in the third century the objection was put in writing by one of the sharpest minds of the age, and the answer, written by his former colleague, became the founding defence of ritual magic in the West.
This study reads that answer, On the Mysteries, beside its full text in the Reading Room, in Thomas Taylor's translation of 1821.
Two philosophers and a letter
Both men were Neoplatonists, followers of Plato as reread by Plotinus (c. 205–270), for whom all things flow from the One through Mind and Soul, and the soul's task is to return. Porphyry (c. 234–c. 305) was Plotinus's pupil and editor. Like his teacher, he believed that the return happened through philosophy: purification of the mind, contemplation, ascent by thought.
Porphyry wrote a letter to an Egyptian priest called Anebo, full of pointed questions about the religion he saw around him. It survives only in quotations, and the Reading Room text gives it first, as The Epistle of Porphyry to the Egyptian Anebo. Its tone is polite and relentless:
"I am likewise dubious with respect to sacrifices, what utility or power they possess in the universe, and with the Gods, and on what account they are performed." (The Epistle)
He asks how gods can be told from daemons, why the gods are invoked as if they could be moved, why diviners need special conditions, why priests use "barbarous" names, and whether the whole business is not a matter of the soul deceiving itself.
The answer comes not from Anebo but from "the Preceptor Abammon", his teacher. Since antiquity it has been attributed to Iamblichus (c. 245–c. 325), a Syrian philosopher who taught at Apamea and who had studied with Porphyry before going his own way. Writing in the voice of an Egyptian priest let Iamblichus speak with the authority of the oldest religion his readers knew. The title we use, On the Mysteries of the Egyptians, was given to the book in the Renaissance by Marsilio Ficino, who made a Latin paraphrase of it in 1497.
Lesson 2 of 6 · 30 min
READ THE SOURCE
- On the Mysteries · Iamblichus, c. 300 CE; English 1821 · free in the Reading Room
- The Chaldæan Oracles of Zoroaster · Attributed to Julian the Theurgist (2nd century), 2nd century; this edition 1895 · free in the Reading Room
- The Hymns of Orpheus · Attributed to Orpheus, c. 2nd–3rd century CE; English 1792 · free in the Reading Room