Spiritualism and Mediumship · Lesson 1 of 7 · Free
The Rochester Rappings
❦
How a movement began in a farmhouse in western New York in 1848. Swedenborg's heaven, Mesmer's magnetic sleep and the Poughkeepsie Seer prepared the ground; then the Fox sisters asked Mr Splitfoot to do as they did. This lesson follows the raps to Rochester and New York, then to the doctors of Buffalo and the confession of 1888.
Spiritualism is the belief that the dead live on as themselves and can speak to the living, usually through gifted people called mediums. It is also the movement built on that belief, which began in 1848 and within ten years had believers on both sides of the Atlantic. Spiritualists seldom called what they did magic. They thought of it as a science, or as a religion, or as both: the dead came freely, and they were asked rather than commanded. Yet Spiritualism changed modern occultism more than almost anything else in the nineteenth century. Theosophy grew out of it, the Golden Dawn defined itself against it, and Wicca borrowed its Summerland (The Goddess, the God and the Year).
This course follows the movement from its start in a farmhouse to the séance, the mediums, the scientists who tested them, the churches, the courts and the occultists. Through all of it runs a single question: what was really happening in the dark?
The Fox sisters, Margaret, Catherine and Leah, ‘the original mediums of the mysterious noises at Rochester’, a Currier lithograph of 1852. Library of Congress. · Public domain · Source
Before Hydesville
The ground had been prepared for a century.
Emanuel Swedenborg (1688–1772), a Swedish mining engineer and natural philosopher, began in the 1740s to describe visits to heaven and hell and conversations with angels and the dead. In Heaven and Hell (1758) the afterlife is a spiritual world much like this one, with houses, cities and societies, where the dead go on growing and every angel was once a human being. It was a homely heaven, and the Spiritualists took it over almost whole.
Franz Anton Mesmer (1734–1815) taught in Vienna and, from 1778, in Paris that an invisible fluid, animal magnetism, flowed through all living things and could be directed to heal. A royal commission of 1784, whose members included Benjamin Franklin and Antoine Lavoisier, put the effects down to imagination. That same year Mesmer's follower the Marquis de Puységur found that magnetised people could fall into a "magnetic sleep" in which they spoke fluently and seemed to see inside the sick. Travelling mesmerists were filling American lecture halls by the 1830s and 1840s.
Andrew Jackson Davis (1826–1910), a shoemaker's apprentice who called himself "the Poughkeepsie Seer", was mesmerised in 1843 and found he could diagnose illness in trance. Between 1845 and 1847 he dictated in that state a huge book, The Principles of Nature (1847), part of which turned out to be lifted from Swedenborg. Davis described a spirit world of spheres and a land of rest he called the Summerland. He wrote later that at daybreak on 31 March 1848 he heard a voice say the good work had begun.
The Shakers, a celibate Christian community, went through an "Era of Manifestations" from 1837. In their villages young women fell into trances and brought back songs, dances and drawings that they said were gifts from the spirits.
Western New York, where Hydesville lay, was known as the "burned-over district" because so many religious revivals had swept it. Within a few decades it had produced Mormonism, the Millerites, who expected the end of the world in 1844, and a great deal else. Its people were used to new revelations.
Lesson 1 of 7 · 15 min
The letter at dawn. Original AI illustration created for Occultum.
This week in magic
One email each Thursday morning: the Moon and the festivals of the week, the angel of each day, and a free lesson to read. Free, and you can stop it in one click.
We use your address only for this email. See our privacy policy.
Spiritualism is the belief that the dead live on as themselves and can speak to the living, usually through gifted people called mediums. It is also the movement built on that belief, which began in 1848 and within ten years had believers on both sides of the Atlantic. Spiritualists seldom called what they did magic. They thought of it as a science, or as a religion, or as both: the dead came freely, and they were asked rather than commanded. Yet Spiritualism changed modern occultism more than almost anything else in the nineteenth century. Theosophy grew out of it, the Golden Dawn defined itself against it, and Wicca borrowed its Summerland (The Goddess, the God and the Year).
This course follows the movement from its start in a farmhouse to the séance, the mediums, the scientists who tested them, the churches, the courts and the occultists. Through all of it runs a single question: what was really happening in the dark?
The Fox sisters, Margaret, Catherine and Leah, ‘the original mediums of the mysterious noises at Rochester’, a Currier lithograph of 1852. Library of Congress. · Public domain · Source
Before Hydesville
The ground had been prepared for a century.
Emanuel Swedenborg (1688–1772), a Swedish mining engineer and natural philosopher, began in the 1740s to describe visits to heaven and hell and conversations with angels and the dead. In Heaven and Hell (1758) the afterlife is a spiritual world much like this one, with houses, cities and societies, where the dead go on growing and every angel was once a human being. It was a homely heaven, and the Spiritualists took it over almost whole.
Franz Anton Mesmer (1734–1815) taught in Vienna and, from 1778, in Paris that an invisible fluid, animal magnetism, flowed through all living things and could be directed to heal. A royal commission of 1784, whose members included Benjamin Franklin and Antoine Lavoisier, put the effects down to imagination. That same year Mesmer's follower the Marquis de Puységur found that magnetised people could fall into a "magnetic sleep" in which they spoke fluently and seemed to see inside the sick. Travelling mesmerists were filling American lecture halls by the 1830s and 1840s.
Andrew Jackson Davis (1826–1910), a shoemaker's apprentice who called himself "the Poughkeepsie Seer", was mesmerised in 1843 and found he could diagnose illness in trance. Between 1845 and 1847 he dictated in that state a huge book, The Principles of Nature (1847), part of which turned out to be lifted from Swedenborg. Davis described a spirit world of spheres and a land of rest he called the Summerland. He wrote later that at daybreak on 31 March 1848 he heard a voice say the good work had begun.
The Shakers, a celibate Christian community, went through an "Era of Manifestations" from 1837. In their villages young women fell into trances and brought back songs, dances and drawings that they said were gifts from the spirits.
Western New York, where Hydesville lay, was known as the "burned-over district" because so many religious revivals had swept it. Within a few decades it had produced Mormonism, the Millerites, who expected the end of the world in 1844, and a great deal else. Its people were used to new revelations.
The house at Hydesville
In December 1847 John and Margaret Fox, Methodist farmers, moved into a rented cottage at Hydesville, near Rochester, with their two youngest daughters: Margaret, known as Maggie, who was about fourteen, and Kate, about eleven. Through the winter there were knocks at night that no one could account for.
On the evening of 31 March 1848, the story goes, Kate snapped her fingers and called out, "Mr Splitfoot, do as I do". Splitfoot was a country name for the Devil, after his cloven hoof. The knocks answered, snap for snap. Mrs Fox asked the raps to count out the ages of her children, and they did so correctly. Neighbours were brought in and questions were put. By an alphabet of knocks the "spirit" said it was a pedlar who had been murdered in the house and buried in the cellar; later accounts gave his name as Charles B. Rosna. The cellar was dug and nothing certain was found. The rumour of a body lasted, and in 1904 bones and a pedlar's box were reported found behind a cellar wall, but almost certainly as a hoax.
Within weeks a local writer, E. E. Lewis, had printed the family's and the neighbours' signed statements as A Report of the Mysterious Noises (1848). The Fox sisters' much older sister Leah Fox Fish took the girls to Rochester, where the raps followed them and began to spell out messages from other dead people. Leah soon found she was a medium herself, and she managed the family's career for years.
Rochester and New York
On 14 November 1849 the sisters appeared before a paying audience at Corinthian Hall in Rochester. Committees of citizens were chosen to examine them, and each reported that it could not find out how the raps were made. On the third night a crowd threatened violence and the police had to step in. In 1850 Leah, Maggie and Kate held séances in New York for paying sitters; the editor Horace Greeley wrote about them warmly in his New York Tribune. Other mediums appeared in dozens of towns, and the "spirit rappings" became a craze.
The talk of the day was of the electric telegraph, which Samuel Morse had first demonstrated over a public line in 1844. Spiritualists borrowed it: the raps were a spiritual telegraph, a line between the worlds, and one of the first Spiritualist newspapers took that name.
The doctors of Buffalo
The doubters were quick too. In February 1851 three physicians at the University of Buffalo, Austin Flint, Charles A. Lee and C. B. Coventry, sat with Leah and Margaret. They concluded that the raps were made by snapping the joints of the knees. When the sisters sat with their feet up on cushions and their heels supported, no raps came. In 1857 a committee of Harvard professors, organised by the Boston Courier with a prize of $500, also saw nothing it could not explain. Believers answered that hostile examiners spoiled the "conditions". The same argument recurs through this whole course, and it is in the Séance Room too.
The confession
The sisters' later lives were hard. Maggie fell in love with the Arctic explorer Elisha Kent Kane, whose family opposed the match; he died in 1857. Kate married a London barrister and was tested in England by the chemist William Crookes (The Investigators). Both sisters drank heavily, and both fell out with Leah.
On 21 October 1888, at the Academy of Music in New York, Maggie stood before an audience of about two thousand, with Kate in a box, and declared that the raps had been a fraud from the beginning. She took off her shoe, put her foot on a stool, and made raps that could be heard across the hall by cracking the joint of her big toe. She said that as children they had first made the noises by dropping apples tied to a string, to frighten their mother. The New York World had paid for her story, and a journalist published it as The Death-Blow to Spiritualism (1888). A year later, on 20 November 1889, she took the confession back. Kate died in 1892 and Maggie in 1893, both poor.
By then the movement no longer needed them. It had its own newspapers, lecturers, camps and hymns, and mediums on both sides of the Atlantic. No one counted its believers reliably, and the claims ran from hundreds of thousands to millions. Spiritualists replied, as they still do, that one confession, later withdrawn, could not explain away the evidence of countless sittings. Critics replied that the first and most famous evidence of all had been a girl's toe.
What Spiritualism claimed
Through all its varieties, nineteenth-century Spiritualism held a few things in common:
The dead survive as themselves, with their memories and characters, in a spirit world that is often pictured as a series of spheres or as a summer country.
They are close at hand, and many of them want to speak to those they left behind.
They speak through mediums, people sensitive enough to receive them, and by phenomena: raps, moving tables, voices and messages.
All of this is evidence: the proof of survival comes from experiment and observation, not from faith or the churches.
There is no eternal hell. Souls go on progressing after death.
That last point mattered a great deal. Many of the first Spiritualists were radicals who had left the hard Calvinism of their parents' churches, and they took up the abolition of slavery and the rights of women (The Spiritualist Church). In an age when many children died young, the movement promised mothers that their children were safe and could still be heard. Its comfort is easy to understand, whatever one makes of the raps.
Exercise
Open the Séance Room and choose the Hydesville raps. Sit once with no controls, then again with the medium's feet on cushions, as the doctors of Buffalo did, and note what changes. Then write in your journal the questions you would have asked at Hydesville in April 1848 if you had been one of the neighbours. Which of them could the raps have answered without any spirit, and which would have been a real test?
TRY IT NOW
Sit in the Séance Room for its account of a sitting.
Reading once is not remembering. Study Cards bring each fact back just before you would forget it, until it is yours.
☉This lesson's 5 questionsNot practised yet · they join your daily review when you mark the lesson completeQuiz me on them →
Ask the tutor
Members can ask questions about any lesson and get an answer grounded in the lesson and its sources — explanations, practical guidance and what to study next.